Technical Reports and Occasional Papers

tech report

Social and Cultural Dimensions of Writing


The following publications focus primarily on the social or cultural dimensions of writing. You may also want to consult the related list of publications focussing on writing's cognitive dimension. Because of the interrelated nature of these topics, many publications are cross-listed.

TR 1. Research in Writing: Past, Present and Future, by Sarah Warshauer Freedman, Anne Haas Dyson, Linda Flower, and Wallace Chafe. This paper reviews the past twenty years of writing research in order to posit a social- cognitive theory of writing and the teaching and learning of writing. The authors provide a constructive rationale for the research mission of the Center for the Study of Writing. (Note: For an updated version of this literature review for a broader audience, see Occasional Paper No. 20.) August, 1987; 61 pages; $4.50.
Order report

TR 2. Unintentional Helping in the Primary Grades: Writing in the Children's World, by Anne Haas Dyson. Dyson explores children's classroom social lives, as revealed during journal time in a first/second grade class. Her analysis of peer social interactions shows such interactions to be key in contributing to and nurturing the skills and values associated with literacy. May, 1987; 29 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 5. Properties of Spoken and Written Language, by Wallace Chafe and Jane Danielewicz. Chafe and Danielewicz discuss important linguistic features that characterize different types of spoken and written language, from dinner conversations to academic papers. Taking into account the cognitive and social demands made on speakers, listeners, writers, and readers in their interactions, they analyze the reasons for these language differences. May, 1987; 27 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 21. Studying Cognition in Context: Introduction to the Study, by Linda Flower (Reading-to-Write Report 1). Reading-to-write is an act of critical literacy central to much of academic discourse. This report introduces the Reading-to-Write project, which examined the cognitive processes of reading-to-write as they were embedded in the social context of a college course. Flower discusses the background to the project and provides an overview of the study design, which included an exploratory study (Technical Report 6) and a teaching study (Technical Reports 22-30). May, 1989; 42 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 28. The Cultural Imperatives Underlying Cognitive Acts, by Kathleen McCormick (Reading-to-Write Report 9). By setting reading-to-write in a broad cultural context, this report explores some of the cultural imperatives that might underlie particular cognitive acts. Protocols and interviews suggest that three culturally-based attitudes played a role in this task: the desire for closure, a belief in objectivity, and a refusal to write about perceived contradictions. May, 1989; 37 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 29. Negotiating Academic Discourse, by Linda Flower (Reading-to-Write Report 10). Academic writing is both a cognitive and social process guided by strategic knowledge--the goals writers set based on their reading of the context, the strategies they invoke, and their awareness of both these processes. This report discusses the difficulties experienced by many college freshmen as they seek to negotiate the transition from a writing process based on comprehension and response to a more fully rhetorical, constructive process. May, 1989; 43 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 30. Expanding the Repertoire: An Anthology of Practical Approaches for the Teaching of Writing, edited by Kathleen McCormick (Reading-to-Write Report 11). This set of classroom approaches, written by teachers collaborating on a course that grew out of the Reading-to- Write project, helps students to explore their assumptions about their own reading and writing processes, become more aware of the cognitive and cultural implications of their choices, and find alternative approaches to the writing task. May, 1989; 77 pages; $5.50.
Order report

TR 33. Social Context and Socially Constructed Texts: The Initiation of a Graduate Student into a Writing Research Community, by Carol Berkenkotter, Thomas N. Huckin, and John Ackerman. The authors explore academic and professional writing as it is shaped by social contexts. They examine a case-study doctoral student's writing development as, over time, he learns how to produce the type of academic prose valued by the professional community in which he is becoming a member. July, 1989; 22 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 36. "Once-upon-a-Time" Reconsidered: The Developmental Dialectic Between Function and Form, by Anne Haas Dyson. Based on a three-year study of writing development in an urban magnet school, this essay traces the evolution of "once-upon-a-time" in a case-study child's classroom story writing. Dyson demonstrates how the story forms young children learn from others are not the end products, but the catalysts, of development. July, 1989; 30 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 42. The Word and the World: Reconceptualizing Written Language Development, or, Do Rainbows Mean a Lot to Little Girls? by Anne Haas Dyson. Arguing that current research has fragmented educators' vision of both written language and literacy development, Dyson offers a more integrated vision that preserves the integrity of written language as a symbol system, suggests five principles characterizing written language development that highlight the dialectical relationship between child construction and adult guidance, and discusses implications for early literacy instruction. April, 1990; 29 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 44. Remediation as Social Construct: Perspectives from an Analysis of Classroom Discourse, by Glynda Hull, Mike Rose, Kay Losey Fraser, and Marisa Castellano. This paper examines remediation as a social construct, as the product of assumptions, perceptions, and beliefs about literacy and learning. The authors illustrate some ways in which notions of learners as remedial, as deficient, can be created and played out in the classroom. They look closely at one college student and detail the interactional processes by which she is being defined as remedial. February, 1991; 30 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 49. Visions of Children as Language Users: Research on Language and Language Education in Early Childhood, by Anne Haas Dyson and Celia Genishi. In this report, Dyson and Genishi review recent research on oral and written language development in early childhood. They discuss how a vision of young children as active participants in a community has been reflected in and has helped shape research themes and current issues in language arts education. June, 1991; 30 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 56. Collaboration and the Construction of Meaning, by Linda Flower and Lorraine Higgins. This study explores the constructive and collaborative process of a group of college freshmen in a writing course. Flower and Higgins discuss the theoretical roots of collaborative planning, look at students' planning as acts of construction and negotiation, and raise questions about the role students' strategic knowledge plays in this social/cognitive process. December, 1991; 74 pages; $5.50.
Order report

TR 57. Technological Indeterminacy: The Role of Classroom Writing Practices in Shaping Computer Use, by Cynthia Greenleaf. This study examines the integration of computers into a remedial high school English class. Greenleaf focuses on writing practices before and after computers were introduced, and concludes that the teacher's structuring of writing instruction had the greatest impact on student writing and the ways computers entered into writing. She argues that computers do not function as independent variables in classrooms, but rather as part of a complex network of social and pedagogical interactions. Winner of NCTE's Promising Researcher Award. January, 1992; 40 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 60. Collaboration Between Children Learning to Write: Can Novices be Masters? by Colette Daiute and Bridget Dalton. Daiute and Dalton explore the role of peer collaboration in literacy development as a case study in the broader inquiry on the social nature of learning and cognitive development. They analyze individual and collaborative stories produced by low-achieving urban third-graders on a computer, as well as transcripts of the talk between collaborative pairs, to illustrate that children can learn and use complex story elements by working with their peers. April, 1992; 54 pages; $4.50.
Order report

TR 63. "Whistle for Willie," Lost Puppies, and Cartoon Dogs: The Sociocultural Dimensions of Young Children's Composing, or, Toward Unmelting Pedagogical Pots, by Anne Haas Dyson. Drawing on data from an urban elementary school, Dyson suggests ways that the "process" approach to teaching writing, in spite of many positive features, may be too rigidly implemented to allow for the needs of young writers in multicultural classrooms. She argues that teachers need to be sensitive to social and cultural diversity and respond with a greater variety of textual models and writing activities in their classrooms. June, 1992; 30 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 67. From Invention to Social Action in Early Childhood Literacy: A Reconceptualization through Dialogue about Difference, by Anne Haas Dyson. Drawing on a recent ethnographic study of child composing in an urban primary school, Dyson contrasts dominant assumptions about appropriate developmental practices (i.e., invented spelling, process writing) with children's interpretations of those practices, interpretations grounded in children's social and cultural worlds. She argues that infusing situatedness and culture into the ways in which educators observe and make sense of children's written language should make "normal" a range of possible pathways to literacy--and "appropriate" a range of ways of teaching. September, 1993; 17 pages; $3.50.
Order report

TR 68. Crossing the Bridge to Practice: Rethinking the Theories of Vygotsky and Bakhtin, by Sarah Warshauer Freedman. Freedman argues that Vygotsky's and Bakhtin's theories of social interaction are so general that they are not always useful guides for classroom practice. A comparison of secondary school classrooms in Great Britain and the United States reveals that when teachers apply similar theories to everyday practice, important pedagogical contrasts remain--both in terms of the ways instruction is organized and in terms of what students produce. May, 1994; 16 pages; $3.50.
Order report

TR 70. The Ninjas, the X-Men, and the Ladies: Playing with Power and Identity in an Urban Primary School, by Anne Haas Dyson. Based on a qualitative study of writing in an urban second grade classroom, Dyson analyzes children's symbolic and social use of superhero stories-- popular media stories that vividly reveal societal beliefs about power and gender, which are themselves interwoven in complex ways with race, class, and physical demeanor. Through the writing and acting of their stories, the children raised issues about who plays whom in whose story. The dialogic processes thus enacted allowed rigid images of gender relations and of glorified power to be rendered more complex. August, 1994; 20 pages; $3.50.
Order report

TR 71. Writing Children: Reinventing the Development of Childhood Literacy, by Anne Haas Dyson. Adult ways of writing about children have traditionally taken for granted the social and ideological worlds of privileged adults. In this essay, Dyson aims to make problematic such writing by reviewing new visions of language and of development that acknowledge human sociocultural and ideological complexity. To more fully explore these new visions, this essay also offers a concrete illustration of writing children as social and ideologically complex beings. It concludes by considering implications for both professional writing and classroom pedagogy. April 1995; 38 pages; $4.00.
Order report

TR 72. Nerds, Normal People, and Homeboys: Asian American Students and the Language of School Success, by Stanford T. Goto. This study is an attempt to complicate current explanations of Asian American success in school. Using ethnographic methods, Goto examines how a group of high- achieving Chinese American high school freshmen perceive themselves as learners and group members, and how these perceptions relate to existing research on Asian American success. He argues that their behavior in school is directly influenced by their perceptions of Asian and non-Asian peers; their awareness of family expectations and status mobility are related but less direct influences. Winner of NCTE's Promising Researcher Award. June 1995; 30 pages; $4.00.
Order report

OP 3. Drawing, Talking and Writing: Rethinking Writing Development, by Anne Haas Dyson. Based on Dyson's studies of primary grade children engaged in journal writing, this paper discusses how children move among and negotiate multiple worlds: the text world they create on paper; the social world that they share with their peers; and the wider experienced world of people, places, events and things. Children's texts thus become increasingly embedded in their lives. February, 1988; 26 pages; $4.00.
Order report

OP 7. The Problem-Solving Processes of Writers and Readers, by Ann S. Rosebery, Linda Flower, Beth Warren, Betsy Bowen, Bertram C. Bruce, Margaret Kantz, and Ann M. Penrose (from a joint project with the Center for the Study of Reading). The authors focus on writing and reading as forms of problem-solving that are shaped by communicative purpose. They examine the kinds of problems that arise as writers and readers attempt to communicate with one another--as writers and readers try to write to a specific audience, for example, or as readers try to interpret an author's meaning--and the strategies they draw upon to resolve those problems. January, 1989; 30 pages; $4.00.
Order report

OP 8. Writing and Reading in the Community, by Robert Gundlach, Marcia Farr, and Jenny Cook-Gumperz (from a joint project with the Center for the Study of Reading). This paper reviews recent scholarship on writing and reading outside of school--that is, in the community, both at home and in the workplace. Gundlach, Farr, and Cook- Gumperz explore writing and reading as social practices and consider the implications of this social view of literacy outside of school for writing and reading instruction in school. March, 1989; 41 pages; $4.00.
Order report

OP 11. Cognition, Context, and Theory-Building, by Linda Flower. In this paper, Flower addresses the debate in composition studies over whether individual cognition or social and cultural context provides the motive force for the writing process. Flower posits the need for a more integrated theoretical vision to explain the interaction between context and cognition. She discusses ways educators might build an interactive vision and how such a vision might improve writing instruction. May, 1989; 27 pages; $4.00.
Order report

OP 17. Toward a Dialectical Theory of Composing, by Stuart Greene. Greene reviews recent social theories of knowledge in composition studies and criticizes the neglect of individual cognition--of how individuals reflect, form judgments, make choices, and construct meaning. He calls for a dialectical cognitive-social epistemic that acknowledges both social and ideological forces as well as cognitive processes in explaining how students learn to write in their chosen disciplines. January, 1990; 19 pages; $3.50.
Order report

OP 22. "This Wooden Shack Place": The Logic of an Unconventional Reading, by Glynda Hull and Mike Rose. Hull and Rose analyze an interaction between Rose and a student in a remedial college composition class, where the student's personal history and cultural background shape an unconventional reading of a poem used in a writing assignment. They discuss the logic of the student's interpretation of the poem, showing the value of conversing with students about interpretations that initially strike the teacher as "a little off the mark." December, 1990; 10 pages; $3.50.
Order report

OP 23. Changing Views of Language in Education and the Implications for Literacy Research: An Interactional Sociological Perspective, by Jenny Cook-Gumperz and John J. Gumperz. This paper discusses the ways in which language has entered into studies in education over the past three decades. The authors suggest that an interactional sociolinguistic perspective, where language in the classroom is seen not just as an abstract grammatical and semantic system but as a process of verbal communication that includes culture-bound and contextual knowledge, has a special usefulness for literacy research. December, 1990; 22 pages; $4.00.
Order report


NCSWL home page | List of topics | Previous topic: Expert/novice | Next topic: Cognition